Companies often tie marketing KPIs to the number of leads. So the marketer optimizes campaigns for cheap clicks and cheap leads, not for deals. Lead count goes up, cost per lead goes down, everyone is happy — except the sales team, drowning in irrelevant contacts.
The cause is measuring at the wrong point. Pay for volume, and the market honestly gives you volume: people who are "just curious," landed on the site by accident or wanted something free. They inflate the top of the funnel and kill conversion further down.
The fix is to shift from "how many leads" to "how many qualified leads, at what cost." A qualified lead matches your customer profile and has shown intent to buy, not just left a phone number. Agree on
what counts as a lead in your sales process and lock the qualification criteria into your CRM.
What changes when you optimize for quality:
- Cost per lead usually goes up — and that's fine. A cheap lead is rarely a target one.
- Cost per deal goes down, because reps work with relevant contacts.
- The forecast gets more accurate, because lead quality stays stable month to month.
- The conflict disappears: sales stops blaming "bad traffic," marketing stops blaming "reps who can't close."
A typical picture from our work: a company cut its lead count almost in half by switching off two "empty" channels, and deals went up. Volume fell, revenue rose.